Being caught up in the national political activities, I was not paying attention to this, so I am grateful to a number of loyal readers who pointed me to the streaming video of the meeting so I could see for myself how the BPC is working with its new members.
As the meeting was being called to order by the chair, it was announced that one member (I think) had sent a message that he would not be able to attend this particular meeting. I noticed that Don Langhrer and whoever was sitting beside him gave each other high-fives at this point - I don't know what that was all about.
Anyway, after listening through about 2/3 of the streaming video, they finally took up the request for the Sonic SUP. After the initial presentation by planning staff, the chair asked if any PC members had any questions for staff.
At this point, new BPC member and VT interior decorator Greg Tew held forth mightily on his expert opinion that the PC did not have the authority to grant an exception on a restriction on parking beyond the front of the structure, citing and misinterpreting some paragraphs from the code.
The chair immediately took 500 points away from Commissioner Tew for not framing this in the form of a question, since this was only the Q&A to town staff part of the meeting, not the preachy soap box part, which comes later.
The town staff member very politely informed Mr. Tew that the actual job of the commissioners was in fact to consider such exceptions and make a ruling on them, which is why all these people were there in the meeting.
Apparently Mr. Tew had just dropped in to pick up his rubber stamp and had accidently found himself in a PC meeting.
Next came some quality public comment time, during which some TaliBURG members pointed out to the PC that just because Sonic had agreed to remove their outside speakers that broadcast "Sonic Radio" music to their patrons, did not mean that people driving up to eat there couldn't roll down their windows and turn up their car radios and pollute the mythologically quiet air hovering over the town with all sorts of redneck republican country music. Emily Satterwhite rose to speak on the subject of light pollution, which she is against and which she believes is created by Sonic Drive-ins. Carol Guest then mumbled a powerful speech lasting well over 13 seconds on the subject of (unintelligible).
Finally Frank Lau took the microphone to remind the PC members that the neighborhood opposition speakers were all loonies, in case anybody didn't get that from their bizarro speeches.
The public comment session was closed and the PC members began a spirited debate over the SUP which consisted mainly of Greg Tew, who has not yet taken the plannng commision training course for new members, instructing the other PC members that they have no authority to do anything, especially approve exceptions to the restrictions of the zoning, while everybody else rolled their eyes and stared at the ceiling.
Finally it was time for the vote, and the SUP was approved with only Mr. Tew voting no, because he didn't like the window treatments.
Now it goes to the Town Council, where they will have a chance to knock it down again.


8 comments:
Actually it was Mr. Tew and the other new member Ms. Moneyhun that voted against the parking part.
Newbies.
Well, I took a little journalistic license. I wrote the Reader's Digest Condensed version. Since I'm not a reporter, I get to do that. I don't know all those people, and the camera angle makes it difficult to connect the name plates with the people sitting at the table sometimes.
Who was sitting on the end, next to Don, and why did they do the high five?
Seriously, does the Town of Blacksburg provide training to new appointees? If so, how radical!!
Michael, I would be happy to sit down with you and discuss the zoning code with you at any time. You can contact me at gregoryhtew@gmail.com.
Regarding my experience, you do have a few things wrong. I am not an interior decorator at Virginia Tech. I am the Interior Design Program Chair in the School of Architecture + Design.
I am also a licensed architect (since 1989) and have worked as an architect in Los Angeles, New York City, Atlanta, and Chicago. Through this work, I have acquired extensive experience using and interpreting zoning and building codes and stand by my position on the SUP for the Sonic project in Blacksburg.
So, while I might by new to the Blacksburg Planning Commission, I think most people would agree that my qualifications are adequate for the responsibility.
I also want to set the record straight on Interior Design at Virginia Tech. Our students and faculty have achieved an ranking of 5th in the nation among about 200 accredited programs. Our graduates work for the best international architecture and design firms in the country.
I am proud to be a member of the Virginia Tech community and more proud to have the opportunity to serve Blacksburg on the Planning Commission. Having lived around the country and traveled much of the world, I can say with confidence that Blacksburg is "A Special Place."
Two comment replies:
First, yes, all commissioners are required to take the planning commissioner certification course during their first year.
Second, in response to Mr. Tew: I seriously think you need to take a chill pill.
From the tone of your comment, I think you are taking this a little too seriously. I mean my blog, not your job.
I am a satirist. I intentionally exaggerate everything to get people to notice the near insanity of many of the things going on around us. Perhaps you don't care for satire. That's ok with me. But I use it to get people to stop contemplating their navels and stop taking everything so seriously. Some things are just not that important.
And of course I checked you out before I mentioned your name in my blog. That is precisely why I was able to refer to you as an interior decorator. Just like I refer to industrial engineers as furniture movers.
So, I know that you have a lot of experience in doing what you do. You don't need to justify that to anybody at this point in your life - your accomplishments should just speak for themselves.
And, I think that your qualifications are at least equal to those of most of the other folks on the planning commission. Take that however you like.
Although you may have had a lot of experience in reading and interpreting building codes and zoning ordinances, that is not the same as understanding the role of the planning commissioner - which is exactly what the town staffer was trying to tell you...repeatedly. As a PC, you do have authority to grant exceptions and approve waivers, at least within some guidelines. As I understood your argument, it was your interpretation that the exception was not allowable because it did not rise to the requirements as you understood them. I think the town staffer and some of the other commissioners were trying to explain to you that was not the case.
In any case, let me give you some advice. Never, under any circumstances, should you respond to something written by somebody like me. It will never, ever turn our good for you. First of all, you need a much thicker skin that you presently have if you are going to be successful in this undertaking, especially in Blacksburg. You are supposed to be above this sort of thing. And secondly, unless you are on my special friend list, and you are not (yet), anything you write to me is fair game for me to exploit in my blog or my newspaper columns. Trust me, it's just not worth it.
Take a lesson from Don L - I have railed on him for years, and have yet to hear a single word in reply.
And finally, I had no intention of challenging the quality of the program you are in at VT. Yeah, yeah, I get it...top 5 programs in the US, students work anywhere they want, yada yada yada.
It's not that I don't believe you. I just don't care.
Well, there was a change in management at the Current, but it doesn't appear that the new guy is any more interested in news than the guy he replaced. Despite the interest and importance of this issue, nothing has appeared in print or on line about the Planning Commission meeting. One wonders why the RT wants to keep this a secret.
Maybe the folks at the RT-NR location want the Sonic to be approved so they have another place they can grab a bit to eat from when doing a story in Blacksburg, so they don't want to give publicity to the BURG'ers of the town.
At times I think we all give the RT too much credit. We think they actually know about the things that are really happening in the NRV AND we think they actually SHOULD care. I'm of the opinion, to borrow a Chris Tre phrase, they might know, but they really don't care. The only thing the RT is interested in in the NRV is the amount of advertising dollars they can skim off the businesses in the region. Their readership and subscriptions are off and declining as I type, but as long as the advertising continues to support the drivel that comes out of that piece of crap supplement called The Current expect more of the same from any "new" staff.
Post a Comment